Skip to content
Left
Continue shopping
Your Order
You have no items in your cart
Login
/
Join
/
$0.00
home
browse
categories
arts & crafts
baby toys & gifts
backpacks/lunchboxes
books
reading books
activity books
building & construction
games
music
novelty/retro
outdoor & active
plush & puppets
pretend play
puzzles
science & nature
GIFT CARDS
HALLOWEEN
Xmas/Hanukah/etc.
ages
0-12 months
1-2 years
3-4 years
5-6 years
7-9 years
10-11 years
12+
top brands
Douglas
Faber-Castell
Fat Brain Toys
Folkmanis
Green Toys
Hape
Jellycat
LEGO
Playmobil
Ravensburger
Usborne
need a recommendation?
about us
who we are
contact us
plush and puppets
269 results
Sort by:
Featured
Best Selling
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Bashful Turtle, Small
$16.50
Merrie Mouse with Candy Cane
$10.99
Bashful Forest Bunny Medium
$25.00
Bashful Fudge Puppy, Small
$16.50
RAINBOW UNICORN PURSE
$16.99
HUMPHREY BEAR - TAUPE
$12.99
Bashful Woodland Cottontail Bunny Medium
$27.50
Bashful Monkey, Medium
$25.00
Bashful Turtle Medium
$25.00
Cyril Sloth
$32.50
Hummingbird (Purple) Finger Puppet
$6.99
Fuddlewuddle Dragon (Medium)
$27.50
MUFFINS TUXEDO CAT
$19.99
Bashful Black & Cream Puppy, Medium
$25.00
Beanie Boo Fiona Cat Mini Clip
$4.99
Otto Sausage Dog
$27.50
Toad Puppet
$34.99
WHITE LOP EARED BUNNY 9"
$19.99
Thatcher Golden Retriever
$10.99
Princess Kitten Pet Carrier
$16.99
BUNBUN BUNNY
$8.99
Bashful Wolf Medium
$25.00
Ribbits Frog
$7.99
Palm Pals Fiesta Taco
$6.99
Mini Baby Axolotl (7")
$24.99
Silver Kitty Palm Pal
$6.99
Tuxedo Cat 10"
$19.99
PomPom Penguin - 6" Brights - Blue
$7.99
Mini Baby Unicorn
$20.99
10" Halloween Squishmallow Cinnamoroll
$24.99
8" Halloween Squishmallow Dalia
$12.99
8" Halloween Squishmallow Dustin
$12.99
5" Halloween Squishmallow Avery
$12.99
Roarie Dino Green Soft
$21.99
Freddie Fox Mini Soft
$12.99
Sasquatch
$12.99
269 results
Left
1
2
3
…
8
Right
