Skip to content
Left Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart

Login / Join /
$0.00
  • home
  • browse
  • categories
    • arts & crafts
    • baby toys & gifts
    • backpacks/lunchboxes
    • books
      • reading books
      • activity books
    • building & construction
    • games
    • music
    • novelty/retro
    • outdoor & active
    • plush & puppets
    • pretend play
    • puzzles
    • science & nature
    • GIFT CARDS
    • EASTER
  • ages
    • 0-12 months
    • 1-2 years
    • 3-4 years
    • 5-6 years
    • 7-9 years
    • 10-11 years
    • 12+
  • top brands
    • Douglas
    • Faber-Castell
    • Fat Brain Toys
    • Folkmanis
    • Green Toys
    • Hape
    • Jellycat
    • LEGO
    • Playmobil
    • Ravensburger
    • Usborne
    • Calico Critters
  • need a recommendation?
  • about us
    • who we are
    • return policy
  • contact us

plush and puppets

124 results
CarPets White Rabbit (glove)
$18.99
My First Puppet - Frog
$10.99
Fluffy Bunny - Pastel Tie Dye
$15.99
Pusheen with Rainbow
$28.99
Rainbow Shimmer Caticorn
$24.99
Baby Putty Nursery Hound
$18.99
Amuseables Val & Tina Love Locks
$40.00
Warm Pals Kitten
$19.99
Stuey Hedgehog W/Mushroom
$12.99
Pteronadon
$18.99
Fresa Strawberry Milk
$7.99
Ax Axolotl
$7.99
Artie Bear Palm Pals
$7.99
Tyrannosaurus Rex
$19.99
KANGAROO
$16.99
Coastal Sparkles Star Mermaid
$21.99
Asian Elephant
$19.99
Diplodocus
$18.99
Giraffe 9''
$12.99
Aurora Miyoni Tots - 11" Golden Retriever Pup
$19.99
Rooster
$19.99
Mini Sitting Frog Finger Puppet
$9.99
Grunting Pig Puppet
$37.99
Sea Turtle Puppet
$34.99
Spotted Owl Mini Puppet
$10.99
Turtle Puppet
$36.99
Smootheez Stegosaurus
$18.99
Fahlo Elephant
$29.99
Fahlo Lion
$29.99
Mushroom Fruit Mashup - Sensory Beadie Squishy Toys
$9.99
Pirate Sockette Knitted
$27.99
Bumble Bee Finger Puppet
$6.99
Dizzy Dreidel Plush
$31.99
Micro Dreidel
$12.99
Bouncer Leggy Octopus
$4.99
Bouncer Fins Shark
$4.99
124 results
  • Left
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • Right
Back to the top
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Ali Cat Toys
200 North Greensboro Street
Carrboro, NC 27510

919-932-3954

Store Hours (now open on Sunday!)

Mon - Fri, 10am - 6pm
Saturday, 10am - 6pm
Sunday, 11am - 4pm

American Express Apple Pay Diners Club Discover Google Pay Mastercard Shop Pay Visa
Copyright © 2025 Ali Cat Toys
Powered by Shopify